Caroline's Oyster Bar Menu
Appetizers
14 itemsCaroline's*
An abundant seafood platter featuring 16 oysters, 12 jumbo Gulf shrimp, 10 oz King Crab, and 8 oz seasonal ceviche.
Seafood Plateau Petite*
A delightful selection of 8 fresh oysters, 8 jumbo Gulf shrimp, and 4 oz of seasonal ceviche.
Chowder Fries
Crispy shoestring fries loaded with creamy clam chowder, melted fontina cheese, and thick-cut bacon.
Burnt Ends
Tender smoked Wagyu brisket burnt ends, tossed in a house BBQ sauce and topped with pickled onions.
Pimento Fritters
Crispy pimento cheese fritters, served with a cool buttermilk dressing.
Local Meat & Cheese Board
A selection of local meats and cheeses, accompanied by grilled sourdough, and house-made pickles.
Point Judith Calamari
Crispy fried Point Judith calamari, served with a delicate lemon aioli and a vibrant blistered tomato sauce.
Crab Hush Puppies
Golden-fried hush puppies bursting with sweet crab meat, served with a zesty lemon aioli.
Warm Crab & Artichoke Dip
A creamy, warm dip featuring lump crab and artichoke hearts, served with crispy corn tortilla chips and fresh vegetable crudité.
Caroline's Oyster Tasting*
A curated selection of six local oysters, each seasonally prepped for a unique tasting experience.
Daily East Coast Oysters*
Fresh East Coast oysters served with a classic mignonette, lemon, and tangy cocktail sauce.
Oysters Rockefeller
Baked oysters topped with rich creamed collards, savory Parmesan breadcrumbs, and crispy bacon.
Guacapoke*
Fresh Ahi Tuna with a kick of wasabi, creamy guacamole, and crispy wonton chips.
Shrimp Cocktail
Chilled jumbo shrimp served with a zesty cocktail sauce and fresh grated horseradish.
Salads
3 itemsHeirloom Tomato & Watermelon Salad
A refreshing salad with sweet heirloom tomatoes, juicy watermelon, creamy whipped feta, a hint of red chili agrodolce, and crispy farro.
Classic Caesar
Crisp romaine lettuce, house-made garlic dressing, crunchy migas croutons, and grated Parmesan cheese.
Green Goddess Kale
A vibrant salad with fresh kale and romaine lettuce, avocado, crunchy pistachios, and grated Parmesan cheese, tossed in a creamy green goddess dressing.
Main Courses
2 itemsChicken & Waffles
Crispy fried chicken served with unique corn & charred green onion waffles, a tangy vegetable chow chow, and sweet habanero-infused honey.
Shrimp & Grits
Classic Southern shrimp and grits featuring charred corn, creamy white cheddar grits, blistered tomatoes, and savory bacon lardons.
Seafood
5 itemsSteamed PEI Mussels
Perfectly steamed Prince Edward Island mussels with savory Andouille sausage, tomato confit, and shallots in a flavorful broth.
Blackened Redfish
Flavorful blackened redfish seasoned with a house rub, served alongside quinoa pilaf and a zesty green tomato relish.
Diver Scallops*
SignaturePan-seared diver scallops paired with thick-cut bacon, a rich egg yolk vinaigrette, and marinated tomatoes.
Glazed Salmon*
SignaturePerfectly glazed salmon served with a savory smoked dashi broth, sweet corn, tender squash, and fresh green beans.
Halibut Fish & Chips
Crispy beer-battered halibut served with golden shoestring fries and a classic tartar sauce.
Sides
6 itemsMac & Cheese
Creamy, baked macaroni and cheese, a comforting and satisfying side dish.
Collards & Ham
Slow-cooked collard greens with savory ham, a classic Southern comfort food.
White Cheddar Grits
Creamy and rich white cheddar grits, a quintessential Southern accompaniment.
Simple Greens
A refreshing side of mixed greens, lightly dressed.
Shoestring Fries
Thin, crispy, and perfectly salted shoestring fries, a classic side for any meal.
Pimento Fritters (Side)
Crispy pimento cheese fritters, a perfect Southern-inspired side dish.
Desserts
2 itemsBeverages
3 itemsLost at Sea NA
A refreshing non-alcoholic blend of pineapple liqueur, creamy Coco Lopez, and fresh kiwi.
Sound & Spirit NA
A non-alcoholic delight featuring pineapple liqueur, guava oleo, and fresh lime for a tropical taste.
Spicy OBX
A refreshing zero-proof cocktail with a spicy habanero syrup, tangy lime, grapefruit, and grapefruit soda.
Cocktails
10 itemsSummer of Amaro
A smoky and aromatic cocktail with Mezcal, Italian Amaro, and bright citrus oil for a unique flavor profile.
Trader Vic's 1944 Mai Tai
Trader Vic's classic 1944 Mai Tai, featuring dark rum, curacao, orgeat, and fresh lime.
Island Prescription
A unique gin-based cocktail with fresh mint, exotic prickly pear, and a splash of zesty Yuzu soda.
Café Noir
A rich and stimulating cocktail with vodka, Italian amaro, bold espresso, and sweet vanilla notes.
Afternoon at Millstone Creek
An infused vodka cocktail with bright lime, refreshing mint, and a hint of ginger for a crisp taste.
No Vacancy
A vibrant cocktail featuring Blanco Tequila, smoky Mezcal, Italian aperitif, exotic passion fruit, fresh lime, and spicy ginger.
Rum on the Hindenberg
An intriguing cocktail with rum, rich port wine, zesty lime, and a spicy ginger kick.
Universal Sound
A sophisticated blend of gin, aperitif, sweet apricot, strawberry oleo, fresh lemon, and a hint of effervescence.
Caroline Signature Old Fashioned
Caroline's signature take on the classic Old Fashioned, featuring smooth bourbon, rich vanilla demerara, and aromatic walnut bitters.
'Watermelon Sugar' Margarita
A refreshing margarita crafted with Reposado Tequila, orange liqueur, sweet watermelon, tart lime, and delicate hibiscus agave.
Wine
17 itemsCabernet Sauvignon Drumheller 2025
A full-bodied Cabernet Sauvignon from Drumheller, Columbia Valley, Washington, featuring robust fruit and firm tannins.
Cabernet Sauvignon Blend Pure Paso by J. Lohr 2024
A bold Cabernet Sauvignon Blend from Pure Paso by J. Lohr, Paso Robles, California, with dark fruit and savory notes.
Meritage Blend Gundlach-Bundschu "Mountain Cuvée" 2024
A sophisticated Meritage Blend from Gundlach-Bundschu 'Mountain Cuvée', Sonoma, California, offering layers of flavor.
Pinot Noir Belle Glos "Clark & Telephone" 2024
An exceptional Pinot Noir from Belle Glos 'Clark & Telephone', Santa Barbara, California, known for its richness and complexity.
Pinot Noir Sea Sun 2024
A smooth Pinot Noir from Sea Sun, Costal Vineyards, California, featuring bright cherry and subtle spice.
Toscano Rosso Il Poggion 2024
A robust Toscano Rosso from Il Poggion, Tuscany, Italy, with deep fruit and earthy notes.
Moet & Chandon "Imperial" Brut
An exquisite Moet & Chandon 'Imperial' Brut Champagne from France, a symbol of luxury and celebration.
Chandon Brut Rosé
A delightful Chandon Brut Rosé from California, offering a festive and elegant sparkling experience.
Giuliana Prosecco
A sparkling Giuliana Prosecco from Veneto, Italy, perfect for celebrations or a light refreshment.
Grenache Daou Vineyards 2024
A crisp and refreshing Rosé Grenache from Daou Vineyards, Paso Robles, California, with bright berry notes.
Chardonnay Cambria 2024
An elegant Chardonnay from Cambria, Santa Maria, California, offering a balanced and nuanced flavor.
Chardonnay Drumheller 2025
A rich and complex Chardonnay from Drumheller, Columbia Valley, Washington, with notes of apple and pear.
Sauvignon Blanc Stoneleigh 2025
A vibrant Sauvignon Blanc from Stoneleigh, Marlborough, New Zealand, known for its intense fruity aromas.
Pinot Grigio Caposaldo 2025
A crisp and refreshing Pinot Grigio from Caposaldo, Delle Venezie, Italy, with bright citrus notes.
White Blend Conundrum 2024
A versatile white blend from Conundrum, California, offering a complex and aromatic profile.
Riesling The Seeker 2024
A delightful Riesling from The Seeker, Mosel, Germany, known for its balanced sweetness and acidity.
Muscadet Jo Landron 2024
A crisp and dry Muscadet from Jo Landron, Loire, France, perfect with seafood.
Beer
9 itemsLegion Juicy Jay IPA
A juicy and aromatic IPA from Legion, bursting with tropical fruit flavors.
Omb Copper
A traditional Altbier from OMB, featuring a balanced malt profile and a smooth finish.
Triple C Golden Boy Blond Ale
A smooth and easy-drinking blond ale from Triple C, perfect for any palate.
Bird Song Higher Ground IPA
A crisp and refreshing IPA from Bird Song, with bright hop aromas and a clean finish.
Wicked Weed Pernicious IPA
A bold and hoppy IPA from Wicked Weed, featuring intense citrus and pine flavors.
Omb Hornet's Nest
A refreshing Hefeweizen from OMB, known for its fruity and spicy notes.
Guinness
A rich and creamy Irish stout with notes of coffee and chocolate.
Stella Artois
A classic European pilsner, crisp and clean with a refreshing taste.
Miller Lite
A light and refreshing classic American lager, perfect for any occasion.